Case A DRM kumulative eller inte

[Mattias Rönnblom]

Jag frågade det här på det amerikanska forumet, men jag passar på och lägger in det här också:

 

Consider the situation described by the picture used by the D3.51 examples.

 

During its PFPh, the Pz IVH in 19X5 fire its CMG at the 4-4-7 in Z5. The CA change related DRM for the two hexspines change with a T type turret is +2 (Case A). Then the Pz IVH fires its MA at the 4-4-7 in Z3. What is the Case A related DRM?

[Klas Malmström]

Jag frågade det här på det amerikanska forumet, men jag passar på och lägger in det här också:

 

Consider the situation described by the picture used by the D3.51 examples.

 

During its PFPh, the Pz IVH in 19X5 fire its CMG at the 4-4-7 in Z5. The CA change related DRM for the two hexspines change with a T type turret is +2 (Case A). Then the Pz IVH fires its MA at the 4-4-7 in Z3. What is the Case A related DRM?

+1

[Mattias Rönnblom]

Är det bara jag som tycker det är konstigt?

[Mattias Rönnblom]

Jag gjorde en hel serie av exempel för att förstå reglerna:

 

Consider the situation described by the picture used by the D3.51 examples. My examples has nothing to do with the D3.51 examples except for using the same picture as a base.

 

EX1: During its PFPh, the Pz IVH in 19X5 fire its CMG at the 4-4-7 in Z5. The CA change related DRM for the two hexspines change with a T type turret is +2 (Case A). Then the Pz IVH fires its MA at the 4-4-7 in Z3. What is the Case A related DRM for that shot?

 

EX2: During its PFPh, the Pz IVH in 19X5 fire its BMG at the 4-4-7 in Z5. The CA change related DRM for the two hexspines change with a NT type change is +4 (Case A). Then the Pz IVH fires its MA at the 4-4-7 in Z3. What is the Case A related DRM for the MA shot?

 

EX3: A T-34 enters hex X3. The Pz IVH fires its CMG as defensive first fire and changes TCA to X4/Y5. Then the T-34 enters hex W4. What is the CA change related DRM if the Pz IVH would turn its TCA and fire its MA? D3.51 says "another target" but this is "the same target". Does it literally have to be a different targets?

 

EX4: A T-34 enters hex X3. The Pz IVH fires its CMG as defensive first fire and changes TCA to X4/Y5. Firing at the same 1 MP expenditure, the Pz IVH turns TCA to X4/W5 and fires its MA. Is it allowed to change its TCA even though the target is already within its current TCA? What is the Case A related DRM for the MA shot?

 

EX5: A T-34 enters hex X3. The Pz IVH fires its BMG as defensive first fire and changes VCA to X4/Y5. At the same 1 MP expenditure, the Pz IV turns the TCA to X4/Y5 and fires its MA. What is the Case A related DRM for the MA shot? What if the Pz IVH had held its MA fire until the T-34 entered W4? What would the Case A related DRM be for that shot?